How to Bring Back Regulars at a Restaurant
To bring back regulars at a restaurant, find out who they are, remember them, give them a simple reason to return, and send a short text or email when they go quiet. It's worth the work: Toast and Resy found that 7% of guests can drive up to 50% of a restaurant's order volume (Toast and Resy Regulars Report 2026).
What the numbers say about regulars
The 2026 Regulars Report from Toast and Resy used Toast order data from the first quarter of 2026, Resy reservations from 2023 through 2025, and a survey of 1,500 U.S. diners in April 2026 (Toast). A few findings every owner should know:
- A small group pays the bills. Up to 50% of order volume can come from 7% of guests.
- Being remembered matters most. 48% of diners said being remembered makes them feel most valued. Only 30% said they always get that. 22% put points first.
- Regulars spend and tip more. 34% of regulars said they spend more per check, and 77% said they tip more where they are regulars.
- Loyalty programs work. Moving a guest into a loyalty program raised their return rate from a 7% baseline to nearly 30%.
- Texts and emails bring people back; search brings new ones. 86% of orders that started from an email and 83% from a text came from people who had already eaten there. 83% of guests who came from a search engine were one and done.
- You don't know most of your guests. 57% of orders on the Toast platform were anonymous.
So the job has two parts. Get names for the people already eating with you, then stay in touch with them.
Step 1: Find your regulars this week
You can't text someone you can't name. Start a list today.
- Pull a report. Most point of sale and reservation systems can sort customers by visits. Export everyone with 3 or more visits in the last 6 months.
- Ask at the counter or the table. "Want a free dessert on your birthday? Leave your name and number." A birthday is a reason people say yes to.
- Use online orders and reservations. Those already carry a name, a phone number and often an email. Make sure the box to hear from you is on the form.
- Write down the ones you know by face. Ask your servers and bartenders for 10 names each.
Aim for your first 50 names by the end of the week. Get each person's OK before you text or email them, and give them an easy way to stop.
Step 2: Remember them on purpose
Since being remembered ranked first in the Toast survey, this is the cheapest step with the biggest payoff.
- Keep a note for each regular: name, usual order, usual night, anything they told you (a kid's name, an allergy to watch for, a favorite table).
- Go over the night's reservations in the preshift meeting and name the regulars on the book.
- Greet them by name and say the usual before they do.
- When they try something new, write that down too.
Step 3: Give them a reason to come back
Pick one reward and keep it simple enough that staff can explain it in one sentence.
- Casual spots, pizzerias, cafes, counters: cash back or a visit card. Toast found cashback rewards drove 24% to 26% retention over 90 days at casual spots like pizzerias and cafes.
- Full service and fine dining: a reward tied to a dish, like a free appetizer on the fifth visit or first taste of a new menu item. In fine dining, an item based reward drove 20% retention against 13% for cash back.
- Everyone: a birthday treat, sent a week ahead so they book.
Whatever you pick, put it on the receipt, on a table card and in the first text you send.
Step 4: Win back the ones who went quiet
Every regular has a normal rhythm. When someone who came weekly hasn't been in for a month, reach out before the habit is gone.
- Each Monday, list regulars who haven't visited in 30 days (45 for spots people visit monthly).
- Send one short, personal text. For example: "Hi Marco, it's Lena from the restaurant. We haven't seen you in a bit. The short rib is back this week. Your next appetizer is on us."
- If they come back, thank them by name. If they don't, try once more in 2 weeks, then leave it.
Also ask why. In the Toast survey, 43% of diners who stopped going to a favorite spot pointed to a slow slide: food quality (31%), price increases (22%) or service (15%). If 3 regulars tell you the same thing, that's your fix for the month.
Step 5: Keep new guests coming in the door
Regulars start as first timers, and most first timers find you on Google. Keep your profile fresh and your reviews coming. Our guide on getting more Google reviews works the same way for a restaurant, and how often to post covers the posting side. Then make sure every new guest gets asked for a name before they leave, so they land on your list.
A weekly routine that takes 30 minutes
- Monday: pull the list of regulars who went quiet and send the texts.
- Tuesday: add the new names from last week's orders, reservations and table cards.
- Before each shift: name the regulars on the book.
- Friday: count how many regulars visited this week and how many of last week's texts came back.
Two numbers tell you if it's working: regular visits per week, and the share of win back texts that turn into a visit.
The Owner's Page runs this from one page for $20 a month. It keeps your customer list, flags the regulars who stopped coming, writes the text for you to OK, and shows sales, Google reviews and posts next to it. You answer 2 questions and your page is built. See the page for restaurants.
See a finished example for your kind of business, then make it yours. Sales, customers, Google and posts in one place. $0 to look. $20 a month when you turn it on.
See an example pageQuestions
How do I know who my regulars are without a loyalty app?
Sort your point of sale or reservation system by visits and export anyone with 3 or more in the last 6 months. Add the names your staff know by face, and ask guests for a name and number with a birthday treat as the reason.
Should I text or email my regulars?
Both work for people who already know you. In the Toast and Resy report, 86% of email orders and 83% of text orders came from guests who had eaten there before. Use texts for short win back notes and email for menu news and events.
What is a good reward for restaurant regulars?
At casual spots, cash back or a visit card. Toast saw 24% to 26% 90 day retention from cashback at places like pizzerias and cafes. In fine dining, a free dish worked better than cash back, 20% against 13%.
How often can I text customers without bugging them?
Get their OK first and give an easy way to stop. Then keep it to a win back note when they go quiet, a birthday note, and the occasional menu news, not a text every day.
Why did my regular stop coming in?
Ask them. In the Toast survey, 43% of diners who left a favorite spot pointed to a slow slide in food quality, prices or service. If several regulars say the same thing, fix that first.
How long until a regular counts as lost?
Go by their usual rhythm. Someone who came weekly and has been gone 30 days needs a note now. For monthly guests, wait about 45 days.